State counsel Kaduna State Ministry of Justice.

Joined the Ministry of Justice Imo State as a state counsel, and rose up to the rank of Senior State Counsel 1983 1986

Chief State Counsel, Ricardo V. Paras III

Counsel submits that the State party has not discharged this burden.

Counsel argued that the State party had not supplied this information to the Committee.

On 13 May 2003, the State party's submission was sent to counsel for comments.

9.1 Counsel submitted comments on the State party's submission on 29 October and 14 November 2003.

9.4 In relation to the complainant's present situation, counsel considers that the State party's information is incorrect.

5.1 By letter of 21 January 2004, counsel disputed the State party's submissions both on admissibility and merits.

Counsel argues that the State party's position also reflects weak confidence in the integrity of the Egyptian guarantees.

4.4 The State party emphasizes that counsel for the corporation was an experienced lawyer specializing in language law.

Having taken into account all information made available to it by the complainant, his counsel and the State party,

5.9 The complainant contests the State party's argument that questioning by his counsel in the examination was not restricted.

Having taken into account all information made available to it by the complainant, her counsel and the State party,

Having taken into account all information made available to it by the complainant, her counsel and the State party,

Having taken into account all information made available to it by the complainant, his counsel and the State party,

The State party indicates that the record was signed by counsel for the defence, without his raising any objection.

11.11 Counsel refers to the State party's apparent unwillingness to further press the Egyptian authorities, with the State party citing possible prejudice to the complainant's legal interests or welfare.

5.1 In a letter dated 21 October 2002, counsel set out her comments on the State party's comments as to admissibility.

(b) That this decision shall be communicated to the State party, to the authors of the communications and to their counsel.

Having taken into account all information made available to it by the complainant of the complaint, his counsel and the State party,

5.7 While accepting that Egypt is a State party to the Convention, counsel observes that this formal act is regrettably no guarantee that a State party will abide by the commitments assumed.

So render good counsel if good counsel will avail.

So render good counsel if good counsel will avail.

As both complaints were submitted by the same counsel, the present complaint places an unnecessary burden both on the Committee and the State party.

11.3 Following renewed allegations of ill treatment by the complainant's counsel, his Egyptian lawyer and NGOs, the State party's Government made further investigative efforts.

Furthermore, in January 2003 counsel for Hanan Attia appended a briefing note from Amnesty International in London to his own observations, from which it was clear that counsel had made the State party's observations of 8 March 2002 available to Amnesty International.

So render good counsel, for you are simply required to counsel,

So render good counsel, for you are simply required to counsel,

(2) The Legal Counsel of WIPO considered the case of an international organization requiring a member State to commit an internationally unlawful act, and wrote

5.1 By letter of 6 January 2003, counsel for the complainant was requested to make any comments on the State party's submissions within six weeks.

4.4 The State party recalls that the author and his counsel were repeatedly summoned to the court hearings, and that both testified before the courts.

Counsel declined.

The State guarantees the access of the citizens to the courts and guarantees defendants the right to counsel and the right to assistance and legal aid.

As to the confidential report, the State party submits that a copy of the report was sent to the complainant's former counsel on 19 May 2003.

The State party adds that the judges concerned had said that they had no objection to the author's counsel being present while they were being heard.

Deputy International Tax Counsel, Office of International Tax Counsel, Department of the Treasury.

9.2 Concerning the reasons put forward by the State party for enforcing the deportation order, counsel maintains that the complainant trained as a fighter pilot in Poland.

Comments by counsel

(represented by counsel)

(represented by counsel)

Panel of Counsel

Previous positions include associate, International Tax Counsel, Office of International Tax Counsel Attorney advisor, Office of International Tax Counsel and associate, Cleary, Gottlieb, Steen and Hamilton.

6.7 By note of 23 April 2004, the State party submits that the new documentation from counsel is too late and should not be considered by the Committee.

Supplementary submissions by counsel